ACOPF CUDA

set	device	problems	Ipopt			master			current
set	device	problems	solved	SGM (s)	SSGM	solved	SGM (s)	SSGM	solved	SGM (s)	SSGM
ACOPF	CUDA	54/132	54	2.07	1	52	2.10	1	52	2.10	1

Outcomes

solver	solved	time limit	iteration limit	other failure	not run yet
Ipopt	123	9	0	0	0
master	124	0	7	1	0
current	52	0	2	0	78

Solved by problem size

solver	small	medium	large
Ipopt	58/58	50/51	15/23
master	56/58	50/51	18/23
current	51/53	1/1	0/0

Performance profiles

Over the 54 instances that all of them have a result for. A curve gives the share of them solved within a factor of the best.

Ipoptmastercurrent

Wall time

Iterations

Time breakdown

solver	total (s)	linear solver	evaluations	initialization	other
master	911.8	53.7%	14.9%	6.0%	25.3%
current	84.6	35.7%	23.6%	2.9%	37.8%

Result files: Intel R Xeon R Gold 6148 CPU 2.40GHz, Quadro RTX 6000

Instances

nv, nc: variables, constraints. st: ok solved, a solved to the acceptable level, t time limit, i iteration limit, f other failure; click it for the solver log. it: iterations. inf: infeasibility. nfac, nsol: factorizations, linear solves. nf, ng, nc, nj, nh: evaluations of the objective, gradient, constraints, Jacobian, Hessian.

Failures only

instance	nv	nc	Ipopt												master												current
instance	nv	nc	st	it	t (s)	obj	inf	nfac	nsol	nf	ng	nc	nj	nh	st	it	t (s)	obj	inf	nfac	nsol	nf	ng	nc	nj	nh	st	it	t (s)	obj	inf	nfac	nsol	nf	ng	nc	nj	nh
case10000_goc_polar	76804	112352	ok	84	68.994	1.35403e+06	2.7e-08	0	0	85	85	85	85	84	ok	65	1.745	1.35403e+06	7.7e-10	125	155	69	66	69	66	65	–
case10000_goc_rect	76804	122352	ok	84	79.377	1.35403e+06	2.6e-08	0	0	85	85	85	85	84	ok	64	1.819	1.35403e+06	7.5e-10	121	187	65	65	65	65	64	–
case10192_epigrids_polar	89850	139456	ok	58	92.592	1.68692e+06	8.5e-11	0	0	101	59	101	59	58	ok	58	2.776	1.68692e+06	4.5e-11	132	337	95	59	95	59	58	–
case10192_epigrids_rect	89850	149645	ok	58	76.358	1.68692e+06	8.5e-11	0	0	105	59	105	59	58	ok	56	2.697	1.68692e+06	4.5e-11	128	305	94	57	94	57	56	–
case10480_goc_polar	96750	150874	ok	70	183.253	2.31465e+06	1.1e-07	0	0	71	71	71	71	70	ok	68	3.347	2.31465e+06	5.4e-09	151	277	69	69	69	69	68	–
case10480_goc_rect	96750	161354	t	3000	600.000	2.24786e+06	1.4e-01	0	0	15322	2525	15322	3064	3000	i	3000	67.999	2.35807e+06	3.1e+00	3129	3148	3092	2998	3164	3024	3000	–
case118_ieee_polar	1088	1539	ok	29	0.231	97213.6	6.9e-09	0	0	31	30	31	30	29	ok	28	0.189	97213.6	7.6e-10	44	84	34	29	34	29	28	ok	28	0.148	97213.6	7.6e-10	45	85	32	29	32	29	28
case118_ieee_rect	1088	1657	ok	29	0.852	97213.6	6.9e-09	0	0	31	30	31	30	29	ok	27	0.151	97213.6	6.6e-09	43	72	31	28	31	28	27	ok	27	0.151	97213.6	6.6e-09	45	85	31	28	31	28	27
case1354_pegase_polar	11192	16646	ok	49	4.013	1.25884e+06	2.5e-08	0	0	72	50	72	50	49	ok	53	0.431	1.25884e+06	9.4e-09	103	148	91	54	91	54	53	ok	53	0.432	1.25884e+06	9.4e-09	103	158	91	54	91	54	53
case1354_pegase_rect	11192	18000	ok	50	4.471	1.25884e+06	2.5e-08	0	0	89	51	89	51	50	ok	53	0.417	1.25884e+06	9.4e-09	102	147	91	54	91	54	53	ok	53	0.420	1.25884e+06	9.4e-09	103	150	91	54	91	54	53
case13659_pegase_polar	117370	170588	ok	66	75.782	8.94805e+06	7.1e-08	0	0	79	67	79	67	66	ok	64	2.878	8.94805e+06	8.6e-09	157	158	69	65	69	65	64	–
case13659_pegase_rect	117370	184247	ok	59	68.705	8.94805e+06	7.1e-08	0	0	63	60	63	60	59	ok	64	2.873	8.94805e+06	8.2e-09	158	153	73	65	73	65	64	–
case14_ieee_polar	118	169	ok	15	0.362	2178.08	3.1e-13	0	0	18	16	18	16	15	ok	16	0.080	2178.08	2.6e-15	16	60	21	17	21	17	16	ok	16	0.079	2178.08	4.6e-15	16	56	21	17	21	17	16
case14_ieee_rect	118	183	ok	15	0.439	2178.08	8.2e-14	0	0	17	16	17	16	15	ok	15	0.077	2178.08	2.2e-15	15	50	20	16	20	16	15	ok	15	0.087	2178.08	7.1e-15	15	56	20	16	20	16	15
case162_ieee_dtc_polar	1484	2313	ok	27	1.017	108076	5.1e-10	0	0	37	28	37	28	27	ok	39	0.219	108076	8.2e-14	66	113	46	40	46	40	39	ok	39	0.208	108076	8.2e-14	68	90	46	40	46	40	39
case162_ieee_dtc_rect	1484	2475	ok	27	0.575	108076	2.9e-10	0	0	39	28	39	28	27	ok	42	0.269	108076	8.2e-14	72	135	52	43	52	43	42	ok	42	0.251	108076	7.8e-14	72	119	50	43	50	43	42
case179_goc_polar	1468	2200	ok	46	1.107	754266	1.5e-11	0	0	51	47	51	47	46	ok	41	0.327	754266	1.9e-09	94	293	86	42	86	42	41	ok	34	0.197	754266	3.6e-12	78	98	59	35	59	35	34
case179_goc_rect	1468	2379	ok	47	0.787	754266	1.4e-11	0	0	55	48	55	48	47	ok	32	0.254	754266	1.2e-11	74	95	58	33	58	33	32	ok	32	0.205	754266	1.5e-11	71	122	58	33	58	33	32
case1803_snem_polar	15246	23172	ok	66	7.703	98334.5	5.9e-10	0	0	76	67	76	67	66	ok	65	0.482	98334.5	5.2e-09	126	167	71	66	71	66	65	ok	67	0.511	98334.5	5.2e-09	132	198	87	68	87	68	67
case1803_snem_rect	15246	24975	ok	66	9.813	98334.5	5.5e-10	0	0	77	67	77	67	66	ok	63	0.531	98334.5	5.1e-09	141	127	74	64	74	64	63	ok	63	0.473	98334.5	5.1e-09	142	141	74	64	74	64	63
case1888_rte_polar	14480	21494	ok	164	16.349	1.40253e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	461	165	461	170	164	i	3000	28.301	1.69134e+06	1.9e-02	5383	6290	6234	2989	12335	3025	2988	i	3000	31.246	1.69116e+06	3.0e-02	6032	5596	10342	3001	16217	3023	3000
case1888_rte_rect	14480	23382	ok	75	9.665	1.40253e+06	4.7e-10	0	0	123	75	123	78	75	i	3000	31.387	1.65445e+06	1.9e-02	5672	6708	8508	3001	14644	3015	3000	i	3000	29.508	1.65211e+06	1.9e-02	6204	5676	8554	2985	11647	3027	2984
case19402_goc_polar	179562	281733	t	75	600.000	1.97782e+06	1.8e-09	0	0	76	76	76	76	75	ok	72	5.743	1.97781e+06	9.5e-10	160	276	73	73	73	73	72	–
case19402_goc_rect	179562	301135	ok	74	218.374	1.97782e+06	1.8e-09	0	0	75	75	75	75	74	ok	72	5.748	1.97781e+06	1.7e-09	161	273	73	73	73	73	72	–
case1951_rte_polar	15018	22075	ok	81	8.168	2.08558e+06	3.7e-07	0	0	153	82	153	86	81	ok	936	7.752	2.08558e+06	3.3e-09	2271	1544	1091	937	1091	939	936	ok	1053	9.718	2.08558e+06	4.9e-09	2402	1777	1519	1054	2230	1056	1053
case1951_rte_rect	15018	24026	ok	134	13.900	2.08558e+06	3.7e-07	0	0	287	129	287	139	134	ok	840	8.267	2.08558e+06	7.0e-09	2035	1506	1346	841	1415	844	840	–
case197_snem_polar	1608	2397	ok	22	0.641	1.50165	2.0e-08	0	0	23	23	23	23	22	ok	31	0.264	1.50165	3.2e-11	59	320	32	32	32	32	31	ok	34	0.276	1.50165	1.1e-11	69	345	35	35	35	35	34
case197_snem_rect	1608	2594	ok	22	0.560	1.50165	1.6e-08	0	0	23	23	23	23	22	ok	34	0.289	1.50165	1.5e-11	69	346	35	35	35	35	34	ok	35	0.278	1.50165	5.0e-12	71	330	36	36	36	36	35
case2000_goc_polar	19008	29432	ok	43	7.448	973432	8.1e-10	0	0	44	44	44	44	43	ok	42	0.579	973432	1.2e-10	77	121	49	43	49	43	42	–
case2000_goc_rect	19008	31432	ok	43	7.223	973432	9.3e-10	0	0	44	44	44	44	43	ok	43	0.547	973432	1.2e-10	79	131	58	44	58	44	43	ok	43	0.566	973432	1.2e-10	81	140	58	44	58	44	43
case200_activ_polar	1456	2116	ok	20	0.348	27557.6	1.1e-09	0	0	23	21	23	21	20	ok	19	0.114	27557.6	1.9e-09	29	68	23	20	23	20	19	ok	19	0.114	27557.6	1.9e-09	29	68	23	20	23	20	19
case200_activ_rect	1456	2316	ok	20	0.410	27557.6	1.1e-09	0	0	23	21	23	21	20	ok	19	0.123	27557.6	1.8e-09	27	86	23	20	23	20	19	ok	19	0.126	27557.6	1.8e-09	29	80	23	20	23	20	19
case20758_epigrids_polar	179236	274918	ok	69	339.976	2.64014e+06	3.5e-07	0	0	72	70	72	70	69	ok	182	13.085	2.61863e+06	4.8e-09	450	1663	267	183	267	183	182	–
case20758_epigrids_rect	179236	295676	t	3000	600.000	2.74588e+06	9.7e+00	0	0	5080	619	5089	3052	3000	i	3000	74.961	2.73958e+06	3.3e+01	3139	3149	3151	2998	3202	3021	2999	–
case2312_goc_polar	17128	25716	ok	46	8.730	441330	2.3e-13	0	0	58	47	58	47	46	ok	45	0.760	441330	1.1e-13	107	321	46	46	46	46	45	ok	45	0.742	441330	2.3e-13	107	313	46	46	46	46	45
case2312_goc_rect	17128	28028	ok	46	6.314	441330	1.1e-13	0	0	59	47	59	47	46	ok	46	0.731	441330	2.3e-13	109	308	48	47	48	47	46	ok	46	0.728	441330	2.3e-13	109	308	48	47	48	47	46
case2383wp_k_polar	17004	25039	ok	60	11.089	1.86819e+06	1.1e-08	0	0	61	61	61	61	60	ok	58	0.595	1.86819e+06	1.2e-09	115	77	59	59	59	59	58	ok	58	0.580	1.86819e+06	1.2e-09	115	77	59	59	59	59	58
case2383wp_k_rect	17004	27422	ok	60	10.182	1.86819e+06	1.1e-08	0	0	61	61	61	61	60	ok	58	0.569	1.86819e+06	1.2e-09	115	79	59	59	59	59	58	ok	58	0.553	1.86819e+06	1.2e-09	115	81	59	59	59	59	58
case240_pserc_polar	2558	3617	ok	161	2.518	3.32967e+06	9.1e-09	0	0	711	162	711	162	161	ok	136	1.482	3.32967e+06	2.3e-10	289	570	601	137	601	137	136	ok	136	1.131	3.32967e+06	2.3e-10	289	580	601	137	601	137	136
case240_pserc_rect	2558	3857	ok	164	2.911	3.32967e+06	9.1e-09	0	0	741	165	741	165	164	ok	136	1.213	3.32967e+06	1.2e-10	289	595	611	137	611	137	136	ok	136	1.154	3.32967e+06	1.2e-10	289	580	606	137	606	137	136
case24464_goc_polar	203374	313641	t	148	600.000	2.62953e+06	8.4e-06	0	0	149	149	149	149	148	ok	65	5.319	2.62953e+06	9.9e-13	148	293	69	66	69	66	65	–
case24464_goc_rect	203374	338105	t	77	600.000	2.62953e+06	4.4e-06	0	0	78	78	78	78	77	ok	63	5.347	2.62953e+06	2.7e-10	143	288	65	64	65	64	63	–
case24_ieee_rts_polar	266	315	ok	19	0.323	63352.2	1.1e-09	0	0	21	20	21	20	19	ok	22	0.133	63352.2	1.6e-14	31	133	29	23	29	23	22	ok	22	0.105	63352.2	1.3e-14	33	61	29	23	29	23	22
case24_ieee_rts_rect	266	339	ok	19	0.230	63352.2	1.1e-09	0	0	21	20	21	20	19	ok	22	0.169	63352.2	1.3e-14	32	99	29	23	29	23	22	ok	22	0.108	63352.2	1.6e-14	33	61	29	23	29	23	22
case2736sp_k_polar	19088	28356	ok	41	7.159	1.30801e+06	1.0e-09	0	0	42	42	42	42	41	ok	44	0.537	1.30801e+06	1.1e-12	85	76	45	45	45	45	44	–
case2736sp_k_rect	19088	31092	ok	40	8.936	1.30801e+06	1.0e-09	0	0	41	41	41	41	40	ok	44	0.633	1.30801e+06	1.1e-12	100	205	45	45	45	45	44	–
case2737sop_k_polar	18988	28358	ok	34	5.922	777728	2.0e-10	0	0	35	35	35	35	34	ok	33	0.397	777727	1.5e-11	64	61	34	34	34	34	33	–
case2737sop_k_rect	18988	31095	ok	34	6.212	777728	2.0e-10	0	0	35	35	35	35	34	ok	33	0.408	777727	1.5e-11	65	65	34	34	34	34	33	–
case2742_goc_polar	24540	38196	ok	106	27.134	275705	4.1e-10	0	0	263	107	263	108	106	ok	235	3.693	275705	1.6e-09	553	589	487	236	487	237	235	–
case2742_goc_rect	24540	40938	ok	184	49.221	275705	4.1e-10	0	0	451	185	451	187	184	ok	238	3.422	275705	2.0e-10	556	569	463	239	464	241	238	–
case2746wop_k_polar	19582	28642	ok	38	6.793	1.20826e+06	2.8e-08	0	0	39	39	39	39	38	ok	38	0.557	1.20826e+06	7.5e-09	90	207	41	39	41	39	38	–
case2746wop_k_rect	19582	31388	ok	36	6.485	1.20826e+06	2.2e-07	0	0	37	37	37	37	36	ok	38	0.560	1.20826e+06	7.5e-09	90	196	40	39	40	39	38	–
case2746wp_k_polar	19520	28446	ok	41	6.195	1.63171e+06	5.2e-08	0	0	42	42	42	42	41	ok	42	0.502	1.63171e+06	9.6e-10	97	85	43	43	43	43	42	–
case2746wp_k_rect	19520	31192	ok	41	7.336	1.63171e+06	5.8e-08	0	0	43	42	43	42	41	ok	42	0.587	1.63171e+06	3.9e-10	95	207	43	43	43	43	42	–
case2848_rte_polar	21822	32129	ok	87	13.120	1.28661e+06	3.4e-09	0	0	133	83	133	90	87	ok	1175	11.498	1.28661e+06	8.2e-09	2907	2144	1384	1176	1384	1178	1175	–
case2848_rte_rect	21822	34977	ok	91	13.785	1.28661e+06	3.4e-09	0	0	180	86	180	95	91	ok	419	4.445	1.28661e+06	5.8e-09	1025	513	435	420	436	422	419	–
case2853_sdet_polar	23028	33154	ok	56	10.073	2.05239e+06	1.4e-13	0	0	59	57	59	57	56	ok	56	0.885	2.05239e+06	5.9e-10	130	266	57	57	57	57	56	–
case2853_sdet_rect	23028	36007	ok	53	9.193	2.05239e+06	1.4e-13	0	0	56	54	56	54	53	ok	54	0.839	2.05239e+06	1.4e-09	126	264	55	55	55	55	54	–
case2868_rte_polar	22090	32393	ok	92	15.978	2.00961e+06	3.3e-09	0	0	161	87	161	95	92	ok	1048	12.209	2.0096e+06	7.1e-10	2619	2237	1171	1049	1171	1052	1048	–
case2868_rte_rect	22090	35261	ok	151	25.928	2.00961e+06	3.3e-09	0	0	559	135	559	154	151	ok	232	2.335	2.0096e+06	4.1e-09	526	351	258	233	259	235	232	–
case2869_pegase_polar	25086	37813	ok	59	11.771	2.46279e+06	4.3e-08	0	0	75	60	75	60	59	ok	61	0.753	2.46279e+06	8.3e-09	120	128	75	62	75	62	61	–
case2869_pegase_rect	25086	40682	ok	60	12.510	2.46279e+06	4.3e-08	0	0	79	61	79	61	60	ok	61	0.694	2.46279e+06	8.3e-09	120	130	75	62	75	62	61	–
case30000_goc_polar	208624	307752	ok	160	409.883	1.14233e+06	2.6e-09	0	0	204	161	204	161	160	ok	163	8.250	1.14233e+06	4.4e-10	384	548	195	164	195	164	163	–
case30000_goc_rect	208624	337752	t	3000	600.000	1.44386e+06	8.9e+00	0	0	3997	162	4010	3016	3000	i	3000	78.711	1.72385e+06	3.1e+00	3212	3474	3293	2998	3343	3036	3000	–
case300_ieee_polar	2382	3478	ok	33	0.855	565220	3.2e-08	0	0	40	34	40	34	33	ok	50	0.287	565220	1.8e-12	91	129	83	51	83	51	50	ok	48	0.275	565220	1.8e-12	88	111	81	49	81	49	48
case300_ieee_rect	2382	3778	ok	33	0.772	565220	3.2e-08	0	0	39	34	39	34	33	ok	49	0.291	565220	1.8e-12	90	138	87	50	87	50	49	ok	47	0.285	565220	1.8e-12	86	126	85	48	85	48	47
case3012wp_k_polar	21082	31029	ok	62	12.862	2.60084e+06	1.9e-07	0	0	63	63	63	63	62	ok	62	0.712	2.60084e+06	2.8e-09	140	261	63	63	63	63	62	–
case3012wp_k_rect	21082	34041	ok	62	9.252	2.60084e+06	1.9e-07	0	0	65	63	65	63	62	ok	61	0.690	2.60084e+06	2.8e-09	139	261	64	62	64	62	61	–
case3022_goc_polar	23238	34990	ok	58	11.895	601384	9.3e-10	0	0	59	59	59	59	58	ok	53	0.978	601384	2.7e-10	127	463	59	54	59	54	53	–
case3022_goc_rect	23238	38012	t	3000	600.000	613167	8.0e+00	0	0	5010	864	5015	3076	3000	f	215	2.788	628310	2.6e+00	396	756	297	213	396	243	216	–
case30_as_polar	236	348	ok	11	0.164	803.127	4.1e-10	0	0	12	12	12	12	11	ok	13	0.074	803.127	7.4e-15	13	49	16	14	16	14	13	ok	13	0.074	803.127	7.1e-15	13	46	16	14	16	14	13
case30_as_rect	236	378	ok	11	0.593	803.127	3.5e-10	0	0	14	12	14	12	11	ok	13	0.086	803.127	9.5e-15	13	43	16	14	16	14	13	ok	13	0.078	803.127	9.3e-15	13	44	16	14	16	14	13
case30_ieee_polar	236	348	ok	18	0.228	8208.52	1.5e-14	0	0	23	19	23	19	18	ok	25	0.123	8208.51	5.4e-15	26	78	40	26	40	26	25	ok	25	0.122	8208.51	1.0e-14	25	78	40	26	40	26	25
case30_ieee_rect	236	378	ok	18	0.667	8208.52	1.2e-14	0	0	23	19	23	19	18	ok	20	0.102	8208.51	7.6e-15	20	69	23	21	23	21	20	ok	20	0.105	8208.51	5.7e-15	20	69	23	21	23	21	20
case3120sp_k_polar	21608	32092	ok	58	9.628	2.14797e+06	5.1e-09	0	0	59	59	59	59	58	ok	53	0.729	2.14797e+06	3.9e-09	123	261	55	54	55	54	53	–
case3120sp_k_rect	21608	35212	ok	58	10.381	2.14797e+06	5.0e-09	0	0	59	59	59	59	58	ok	53	0.795	2.14797e+06	3.9e-09	123	260	54	54	54	54	53	–
case3375wp_k_polar	24350	35876	ok	63	10.492	7.43817e+06	1.1e-06	0	0	64	64	64	64	63	ok	60	0.900	7.43817e+06	3.3e-10	139	282	61	61	61	61	60	–
case3375wp_k_rect	24350	39250	ok	68	11.825	7.43817e+06	1.1e-06	0	0	69	69	69	69	68	ok	61	0.910	7.43817e+06	3.7e-09	140	273	62	62	62	62	61	–
case3970_goc_polar	35270	54428	ok	66	20.899	960985	2.5e-10	0	0	67	67	67	67	66	ok	50	1.207	960984	4.0e-10	115	318	51	51	51	51	50	–
case3970_goc_rect	35270	58398	ok	66	20.676	960985	2.5e-10	0	0	67	67	67	67	66	ok	50	1.239	960984	4.0e-10	115	323	51	51	51	51	50	–
case39_epri_polar	282	401	ok	26	0.342	138416	5.7e-14	0	0	55	27	55	27	26	ok	42	0.232	138416	4.6e-14	71	142	106	43	106	43	42	ok	42	0.225	138416	4.0e-14	72	133	101	43	101	43	42
case39_epri_rect	282	440	ok	27	0.595	138416	5.1e-14	0	0	57	28	57	28	27	ok	42	0.230	138416	4.3e-14	73	126	101	43	101	43	42	ok	42	0.211	138416	4.7e-14	74	106	101	43	101	43	42
case3_lmbd_polar	24	28	ok	16	0.208	5812.64	9.1e-13	0	0	17	17	17	17	16	ok	20	0.107	5812.64	9.1e-13	20	37	22	21	22	21	20	ok	20	0.075	5812.64	9.1e-13	20	37	22	21	22	21	20
case3_lmbd_rect	24	31	ok	15	0.544	5812.64	8.0e-15	0	0	16	16	16	16	15	ok	21	0.082	5812.64	9.1e-13	21	37	23	22	23	22	21	ok	21	0.081	5812.64	9.1e-13	21	39	23	22	23	22	21
case4020_goc_polar	36696	56957	ok	60	24.858	822247	5.4e-05	0	0	61	61	61	61	60	ok	61	1.444	822246	3.3e-12	137	257	62	62	62	62	61	–
case4020_goc_rect	36696	60977	ok	62	29.675	822247	5.4e-05	0	0	63	63	63	63	62	ok	62	1.434	822246	3.3e-12	142	260	63	63	63	63	62	–
case4601_goc_polar	38814	59596	ok	73	24.512	826242	3.8e-09	0	0	74	74	74	74	73	ok	69	1.503	826240	1.5e-11	153	334	70	70	70	70	69	–
case4601_goc_rect	38814	64197	ok	73	26.345	826242	3.8e-09	0	0	75	74	75	74	73	ok	69	1.526	826240	1.5e-11	153	356	70	70	70	70	69	–
case4619_goc_polar	42532	66289	ok	50	22.931	476704	1.8e-09	0	0	51	51	51	51	50	ok	52	1.363	476703	6.9e-12	118	281	53	53	53	53	52	–
case4619_goc_rect	42532	70908	ok	50	20.481	476704	1.8e-09	0	0	51	51	51	51	50	ok	51	1.393	476703	4.4e-10	116	255	52	52	52	52	51	–
case4661_sdet_polar	34758	51302	ok	56	20.062	2.25134e+06	6.3e-08	0	0	57	57	57	57	56	ok	65	1.887	2.25134e+06	6.9e-10	148	287	66	66	66	66	65	–
case4661_sdet_rect	34758	55963	ok	55	17.318	2.25134e+06	9.1e-10	0	0	57	56	57	56	55	ok	64	1.800	2.25134e+06	5.6e-10	146	284	65	65	65	65	64	–
case4837_goc_polar	41398	64030	ok	59	20.539	872255	9.3e-10	0	0	69	60	69	60	59	ok	58	1.267	872255	4.5e-13	132	280	59	59	59	59	58	–
case4837_goc_rect	41398	68867	ok	59	21.104	872255	9.0e-10	0	0	69	60	69	60	59	ok	58	1.293	872255	6.8e-13	132	269	59	59	59	59	58	–
case4917_goc_polar	37872	56917	ok	65	18.570	1.38779e+06	2.3e-13	0	0	68	66	68	66	65	ok	58	1.295	1.38779e+06	7.4e-10	137	368	62	59	62	59	58	–
case4917_goc_rect	37872	61834	ok	66	20.046	1.38779e+06	2.3e-13	0	0	71	67	71	67	66	ok	81	1.654	1.38779e+06	4.6e-09	198	480	100	82	100	83	81	–
case500_goc_polar	4254	6097	ok	40	1.127	454946	4.5e-08	0	0	41	41	41	41	40	ok	40	0.250	454946	2.0e-09	72	104	41	41	41	41	40	ok	40	0.249	454946	2.0e-09	72	113	41	41	41	41	40
case500_goc_rect	4254	6597	ok	41	1.243	454946	4.0e-08	0	0	42	42	42	42	41	ok	40	0.278	454946	6.0e-10	72	102	41	41	41	41	40	ok	40	0.227	454946	2.0e-09	73	87	41	41	41	41	40
case5658_epigrids_polar	48552	74821	ok	51	20.516	1.20731e+06	5.1e-12	0	0	71	52	71	52	51	ok	49	1.348	1.20731e+06	5.9e-12	116	279	55	50	55	50	49	–
case5658_epigrids_rect	48552	80479	ok	50	22.572	1.20731e+06	4.8e-12	0	0	74	51	74	51	50	ok	55	1.505	1.20731e+06	5.9e-12	127	278	77	56	77	56	55	–
case57_ieee_polar	448	675	ok	15	0.272	37589.3	3.7e-11	0	0	16	16	16	16	15	ok	19	0.155	37589.3	5.7e-14	21	108	22	20	22	20	19	ok	19	0.118	37589.3	3.6e-14	21	99	22	20	22	20	19
case57_ieee_rect	448	732	ok	15	0.390	37589.3	3.6e-11	0	0	16	16	16	16	15	ok	19	0.129	37589.3	6.0e-14	24	98	24	20	24	20	19	ok	19	0.138	37589.3	6.4e-14	25	125	24	20	24	20	19
case588_sdet_polar	4110	5979	ok	35	1.005	313140	1.0e-09	0	0	36	36	36	36	35	ok	35	0.267	313140	2.0e-11	82	194	36	36	36	36	35	ok	35	0.274	313140	2.0e-11	82	213	36	36	36	36	35
case588_sdet_rect	4110	6567	ok	35	1.344	313140	1.0e-09	0	0	36	36	36	36	35	ok	33	0.265	313140	4.8e-09	77	177	44	34	44	34	33	ok	33	0.253	313140	6.4e-09	77	177	44	34	44	34	33
case5_pjm_polar	44	53	ok	21	0.627	17551.9	3.5e-14	0	0	28	22	28	22	21	ok	29	0.145	17551.9	3.3e-14	41	107	55	30	55	30	29	ok	30	0.148	17551.9	1.9e-14	44	100	55	31	55	31	30
case5_pjm_rect	44	58	ok	21	0.550	17551.9	3.6e-14	0	0	28	22	28	22	21	ok	29	0.168	17551.9	2.4e-14	42	127	53	30	53	30	29	ok	29	0.157	17551.9	3.5e-14	44	94	55	30	55	30	29
case60_c_polar	518	737	ok	27	0.366	92693.7	2.9e-08	0	0	35	28	35	28	27	ok	29	0.162	92693.7	1.1e-10	52	116	43	30	43	30	29	ok	28	0.150	92693.7	9.4e-11	52	95	42	29	42	29	28
case60_c_rect	518	797	ok	27	0.544	92693.7	1.4e-09	0	0	35	28	35	28	27	ok	28	0.162	92693.7	3.4e-13	62	96	44	29	44	29	28	ok	28	0.201	92693.7	3.7e-13	64	165	44	29	44	29	28
case6468_rte_polar	49734	75937	ok	146	50.035	2.06973e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	287	140	287	150	146	ok	982	14.043	2.06973e+06	1.9e-09	2375	1876	1283	983	1286	985	982	–
case6468_rte_rect	49734	82405	ok	167	71.582	2.06973e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	350	161	350	171	167	ok	400	6.101	2.06973e+06	1.9e-09	921	964	486	401	491	403	400	–
case6470_rte_polar	50482	75976	ok	92	31.382	2.23757e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	119	87	119	94	92	ok	1056	14.950	2.23757e+06	1.9e-09	2651	1883	1257	1057	1262	1060	1056	–
case6470_rte_rect	50482	82446	ok	98	36.234	2.23757e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	165	94	166	100	98	ok	1630	25.514	2.23757e+06	1.9e-09	4026	2852	1723	1631	1728	1635	1630	–
case6495_rte_polar	50426	76124	ok	181	72.470	3.06783e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	218	176	218	183	181	ok	1891	36.935	3.06782e+06	2.9e-09	4610	4433	4297	1892	4767	1899	1891	–
case6495_rte_rect	50426	82619	ok	178	73.130	3.06783e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	220	174	220	180	178	ok	1938	33.223	3.06782e+06	3.0e-09	4794	3739	3677	1939	3796	1943	1938	–
case6515_rte_polar	50546	76290	ok	137	50.331	2.8255e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	189	131	189	139	137	ok	1133	16.933	2.8255e+06	1.9e-09	2716	1708	1279	1134	1281	1138	1133	–
case6515_rte_rect	50546	82805	ok	134	61.483	2.8255e+06	1.9e-09	0	0	201	130	201	136	134	ok	579	9.327	2.8255e+06	1.9e-09	1420	1139	664	580	671	583	579	–
case7336_epigrids_polar	62116	95306	ok	50	26.844	1.88239e+06	1.1e-07	0	0	52	51	52	51	50	ok	55	1.922	1.88239e+06	3.4e-09	127	298	57	56	57	56	55	–
case7336_epigrids_rect	62116	102642	ok	57	39.799	1.88239e+06	1.1e-07	0	0	65	56	65	59	57	ok	54	1.905	1.88239e+06	3.1e-09	124	304	56	55	56	55	54	–
case73_ieee_rts_polar	824	987	ok	24	0.350	189764	2.3e-13	0	0	25	25	25	25	24	ok	27	0.187	189764	4.1e-14	44	107	35	28	35	28	27	ok	27	0.132	189764	2.4e-14	43	80	33	28	33	28	27
case73_ieee_rts_rect	824	1060	ok	24	0.344	189764	2.1e-13	0	0	26	25	26	25	24	ok	27	0.141	189764	2.7e-14	44	95	33	28	33	28	27	ok	27	0.139	189764	3.0e-14	43	84	33	28	33	28	27
case78484_epigrids_polar	674562	1039062	t	59	600.000	1.53375e+07	7.6e-01	0	0	60	60	60	60	59	ok	103	21.915	1.53159e+07	1.2e-09	224	378	104	104	104	104	103	–
case78484_epigrids_rect	674562	1117540	t	57	600.000	1.5341e+07	9.9e-01	0	0	60	58	60	58	57	ok	103	22.011	1.53159e+07	1.2e-09	224	373	104	104	104	104	103	–
case793_goc_polar	5432	7978	ok	37	1.352	260198	1.8e-11	0	0	54	38	54	38	37	ok	37	0.240	260198	1.3e-12	85	79	38	38	38	38	37	ok	37	0.230	260198	6.0e-13	72	86	38	38	38	38	37
case793_goc_rect	5432	8771	ok	36	1.309	260198	2.0e-11	0	0	51	37	51	37	36	ok	37	0.266	260198	6.0e-13	86	73	39	38	39	38	37	ok	37	0.286	260198	5.7e-13	85	205	39	38	39	38	37
case8387_pegase_polar	78748	118702	ok	78	63.956	2.77139e+06	1.8e-12	0	0	79	79	79	79	78	ok	261	8.160	2.77139e+06	1.9e-10	646	1330	316	262	316	262	261	–
case8387_pegase_rect	78748	127089	ok	80	61.234	2.77139e+06	8.5e-12	0	0	86	81	86	81	80	ok	263	7.956	2.77139e+06	1.9e-10	651	1018	311	264	311	264	263	–
case89_pegase_polar	1042	1649	ok	31	0.416	107286	1.9e-07	0	0	66	32	66	32	31	ok	28	0.159	107286	2.9e-11	48	75	31	29	31	29	28	ok	28	0.158	107286	2.9e-11	48	72	31	29	31	29	28
case89_pegase_rect	1042	1738	ok	31	0.376	107286	1.9e-07	0	0	67	32	67	32	31	ok	29	0.170	107286	2.9e-11	51	61	31	30	31	30	29	ok	29	0.152	107286	2.9e-11	51	68	31	30	31	30	29
case9241_pegase_polar	85568	130826	ok	74	62.376	6.24309e+06	3.9e-08	0	0	81	75	81	75	74	i	3000	112.446	6.24278e+06	2.3e-06	6021	13880	27222	3001	27222	3001	3000	–
case9241_pegase_rect	85568	140067	ok	76	62.758	6.24309e+06	4.6e-05	0	0	89	77	89	77	76	i	3000	121.283	6.24276e+06	2.5e-06	6021	13920	29685	3001	29685	3001	3000	–
case9591_goc_polar	83572	130588	ok	70	96.800	1.06168e+06	6.3e-07	0	0	78	71	78	71	70	ok	64	2.919	1.06168e+06	4.6e-11	145	323	65	65	65	65	64	–
case9591_goc_rect	83572	140179	ok	70	92.881	1.06168e+06	6.2e-07	0	0	84	71	84	71	70	ok	64	2.851	1.06168e+06	1.5e-11	144	269	65	65	65	65	64	–